What Liberates Love? John Wineland's Question That Changes How You Handle Disagreements

This post contains affiliate links.

Brittney and I have had the same fight in different forms more times than I can count. The specific content varies — parenting decisions, logistics, the accumulated weight of two people running a life together — but the underlying pattern is recognizable. One of us says something that lands wrong. The other responds from the injury. Position hardens against position. And somewhere in the middle of it, the people who love each other most are treating each other like adversaries.

What I've been working on, drawn partly from John Wineland's framework on devotion and partly from the broader somatic and relational work of the past few years, is a practice of asking a different question in those moments. Not "how do I win this?" Not even "how do I resolve this?" But something more fundamental:

What liberates love right now?

That question — Wineland's framing, drawn from the pillar of his work he calls devotion to the field of love — is one of the most practically useful things I've encountered in years of thinking seriously about relationships.

A joyful couple embraces on the beach, their smiles radiating love and happiness as the sun sets behind them.

Who John Wineland Is

John Wineland is a relationship teacher, speaker, and author of From the Core: A New Masculine Paradigm for Leading with Love, Living Your Truth and Healing the World (affiliate link). His work offers profound insights into the dynamics of leadership, masculine-feminine polarity, and conscious relationships, drawing from more than 30 years of Buddhist meditative practice and 15 years of intensive study in yogic intimacy.

Wineland's framework for relationships rests on what he calls the Four Pillars: intimacy (genuine meeting at a human level), devotion to the field of love, sexual polarity, and the commitment to deep personal work. Each is a cornerstone, and together they become the supports for a relationship not just to survive but to thrive.

The devotion pillar — the second pillar — is where the question "what liberates love?" lives. And understanding it requires understanding what Wineland means by devotion.

The Second Pillar: Devotion to the Field of Love

Devotion, in Wineland's framework, doesn't mean devotion to your partner in the conventional romantic sense. It means devotion to love itself — to the quality of connection and aliveness that exists between two people as something worth protecting and feeding, even when one or both partners are being difficult, reactive, or defended.

The second pillar is about learning to be devotional to your partner's nervous system, and devoted to the liberation of love above all the things that get in the way of it.

That last phrase is the key. Devoted to the liberation of love above all the things that get in the way of it. Not above your ego's need to win. Not above your story about what happened and who was wrong. Above the reaction, the defensiveness, the habitual response that your nervous system defaults to when threatened.

The question "what liberates love right now?" is the operational version of this pillar. It's the practice of pausing — in the middle of a disagreement, in the heat of a reactive moment — and asking: given what's actually happening here, what would cause love to expand rather than contract?

The Three-Stage Conflict Framework

Wineland and his colleague Kendra Cunov developed a three-stage framework for navigating conflict that maps onto this question directly. The framework helps couples map their way through conflict in a way that genuinely creates deeper connection and intimacy rather than simply resolving it.

The first stage is somatic — getting regulated. Before any productive engagement with the content of a disagreement is possible, both people need to be out of the acute stress response that conflict activates. This isn't suppression. It's the recognition that two people in full sympathetic nervous system activation cannot actually hear each other, cannot access genuine empathy, and cannot make good decisions about what to say next. Getting regulated first — through breath, through physical movement, through whatever practice works for each person — is the prerequisite for anything useful happening.

The second stage is genuine listening. Not tactical listening while preparing a rebuttal, but the kind of listening that actually tries to understand your partner's experience rather than build the case against it. What are they actually feeling? What is their experience of what happened, on its own terms, without the filter of your narrative about it? This stage requires enough security to temporarily set aside your own experience and genuinely encounter theirs.

The third stage — where "what liberates love?" most directly applies — is the integration of both people's experiences into something that serves the relationship rather than the individual positions. Not compromise in the sense of both people getting less than they want, but genuine synthesis: what do we both care about underneath our positions, and what would honor both of those things?

At each stage, the animating question is the same: what liberates love right now? In the first stage, the answer might be: regulate, don't engage yet. In the second: listen without defending. In the third: find what we actually both care about.

What the Question Actually Does

The power of "what liberates love?" as a practice lies in what it does to the question you're holding in a difficult moment.

Most of us, when in conflict with our partners, are holding some version of: how do I get my point across? How do I make them understand? How do I protect myself from being wrong? How do I resolve this discomfort?

All of these questions orient the person toward their own position and their own nervous system. They're ego-centered questions, even when the ego is defensive rather than aggressive.

"What liberates love?" orients toward something outside the ego — toward the quality of the relationship itself as something worth serving. It's not a suppression of your own experience. It's an expansion of what you're trying to accomplish. You're not just trying to win an argument or reduce your own discomfort. You're trying to protect and feed something that matters more than either.

For Brittney and me, this question has started to function as a circuit breaker. Not perfectly — I don't always remember it in the heat of a moment, and when I do remember it I don't always have the regulation to act on it. But the practice of returning to it — of asking "what serves the love between us right now" rather than "what serves my position right now" — produces a qualitatively different kind of conflict.

Not conflict-free. But conflict that moves somewhere, that leaves both people feeling more connected rather than less, that treats disagreement as something the relationship can metabolize rather than something that damages it.

The Practice

The application is deceptively simple and genuinely difficult.

In a moment of conflict or disagreement: pause. Not to suppress what you're feeling, but to create a beat between stimulus and response. In that beat, ask the question: What liberates love right now?

Sometimes the answer is: leave the room and regulate before continuing. Sometimes it's: stop talking and actually listen. Sometimes it's: say the thing I've been withholding that's actually underneath my reaction. Sometimes it's: acknowledge what's true in what my partner is saying before defending my own position.

The answer is always specific to the moment. The question is always the same.

What makes this a practice rather than a technique is that it requires something prior to the moment of conflict: the ongoing commitment to love as something worth being devoted to. Wineland's framing is devotional in a specific sense — it treats the love between two people not as a feeling that either exists or doesn't, but as a field that both people are responsible for tending.

You tend it by asking, in the moments when it's most at risk: what would cause it to expand right now?

Ready to go deeper?

If this resonates, there are two ways to take the next step with Coelle.

Download the Coelle app — Guided audio intimacy sessions designed for couples who are ready to stop performing and start arriving. The devotion and presence practices built into Coelle sessions feed exactly the field of love Wineland describes. Download Coelle here.

Work with me directly — I offer one-on-one sex and intimacy coaching for individuals and couples, drawing on my background in sport psychology and years of personal somatic work. Navigating conflict in ways that deepen rather than damage connection is core to the work I do with clients. Learn more about coaching here.